Phacient

  • Who We Are
    • What’s with your name?
  • Why Phacient
  • What We Do
    • Management
    • Marketing
    • Technology
  • Try Us Out
  • Blog
  • Contact Us

On the Need for Common Definition

By Joseph Drasin May 10, 2012

Define_Real_Esate_QualityPeople often argue about if agents are worth what they are paid, who is a good agent, what makes a good agent, and so forth. I’m not (for now) going to dive into any of these questions, but instead step back and try and determine how do we even go about setting up the discussion in order to answer those questions? The more I think about it, the more I come to believe that real estate agents represent a very unusual profession that sells a very unusual good which is why it makes comparisons and evaluation so challenging. If we are going to be able to answer any of the above questions, we need to first dive into the question of “what exactly is a real estate agent”.

Gas_PricesIn economics we learn about many types of goods and how, as a society, we should deal with and evaluate them. For instance, inelastic goods (those which demand is independent of prices) are often watched closely for abuse. Why do you think there is so much outrage over rising gas prices? Prices are going up and there is limited ability to reduce demand or substitute in another good. Alternatively we have goods which appear to be natural monopolies (utilities being the most obvious example) which is why in many areas the power and water companies are either heavily regulated or run by state commissions.

So how does real estate fit into any of this? Well, as it turns out, I cannot find a type of good to accurately describe the role of a real estate agent and the subsequent real-estate transaction. Real estate agents act as advisors (though not legally fiduciaries) but do not come to the table with objective knowledge. The closest I could find is something called an experiential good. This is a good where the actual experience of using the good is in itself the value. Think of a visit to the movie theater or going on vacation; you experience the value. However, with an experiential good you can evaluate the value of it as you experience it. You usually leave a movie theater knowing if you got your $12 worth.

House_ValueWhen it comes to a real estate agent, your ability to evaluate their performance is limited. After you sell your house, you never know if you could have gotten another $10,000. Would the home have sold as well if you hadn’t spent $5,000 fixing it up before sale? Unfortunately we have no way to rerun the same home sale 50 times and answer these questions. There are some comparisons that can be made with law, medicine, and business consulting, but in general those industries deal with more common transactions and are heavily licensed, regulated, and monitored (back to the earlier point).

As someone who has been on both sides of the consulting table, I can say that one of the real challenges with such ‘professional’ goods is developing a valid metric of performance. Moreover, many existing metrics are prone to gaming. For instance there is evidence that, after the introduction of success rate reporting, surgeons becoming overly risk-averse in regards to the patience they will work on. Some typical ones used with real estate agents are of very questionable validity. Is time on market really a good measure? Any economist will tell you that a good that sells quickly is selling too cheaply. Research on the time-on-market and sale price of real estate agent’s own homes supports this (they are on the market longer and sell at higher prices). Is the raw number of homes sold a good measure? The number which sell within 3% of posted price? Buying agents getting more than 5% under list price?
I think what is needed is to begin a conversation around how to address this. We are in a situation where information is becoming increasingly available and can be leveraged to consider some complex questions. What evaluation criteria, both objective and subjective, can we use? How can we avoid building statistics that are so easily gamed? This is the perfect time to take a fresh look at an old industry in a very new way.


Related posts:
Google+ Comments Now Able to Integrate into Your W...
Don't Believe the Hype
Putting an End to the Great Klout Debate

Posted Under:  Blog | Business | Operations | Real Estate Tags:  consumerism | real estate | valuation | value

What Others Say About Us:

"By staying on top of the latest social media and marketing trends and filtering out the fads, Phacient is able to deliver industry-specific solutions through innovative social media avenues." – Joseph Drasin of Prism Consulting Services

"Patrick Healy is leading the digital media revolution. He is a complete digital marketing guru, with a robust skillset that translates into a deft competency to grow your brand online. Brands will be transformed by the Internet when working with Phacient and Patrick." – Matt Browne of SDBloggers

"To put it frankly, Patrick Healy knows what makes your business work day-in and day-out.  He's effective, efficient, and is a straight shooter.  Patrick Healy = High Value." – Ryan Hinricher of Investor Nation

"I have worked directly with Patrick Healy and recommend him highly for his knowledge, integrity, and drive. Phacient will get the job done." – Joe Spake of Spake Communications 

"Patrick Healy is the type of person you want to connect with when need a subject matter expert or if you are looking for someone who can connect you to an expert, an equally important and overlooked attribute." – Chris Metzger of Blair Insurance Group 

"By partnering with Phacient it has helped us to expand our technological footprint in the PEO space by developing our most advanced website for prospects." – Tim Hillert of EasyPEO

"I've known Patrick Healy for approximately 5 years and heartily endorse him and his company, Phacient." – Joe Sheehan of Weichert Realtors

"My association with Patrick Healy has directly and positively affected my business." – Joe Sheehan of Weichert Realtors

"In addition to being knowledgeable about social media, technology, and online marketing, Patrick Healy is knowledgeable about real business functions." – Ryan Hinricher of Investor Nation

"On a recent visit to New York City Patrick Healy introduced some key people to our company. Those connections are still paying dividends." – Berry Enloe of REcake

"Phacient's inside industry knowledge led us to make some decisions that greatly aided us in the development stages of REcake.  Those insights continue to pay off today." – Berry Enloe of REcake

"Patrick Healy has a vision for the Real Estate Industry with the ultimate objective of assisting real estate professionals to provide the highest levels of service to their clients at the best possible price." – Joe Sheehan of Weichert Realtors

"Phacient's Patrick Healy may be the most energetic, knowledgeable, up-to-date and pragmatic expert on social media whom I have encountered. His advice has proved invaluable to me." – Malcolm Carter of Charles Rutenberg Realty

"Phacient was a great asset in the development stages of our company. They know the ins and outs of the industry and was able to guide us in ways that helped us avoid some real pitfalls." – Berry Enloe of REcake

"Since taking the advice of Patrick at Phacient, results of our social networking have increased massively. His continued support affects the entire direction of my business." – Howie Nicholsby of 21st Century Kilts

"Patrick Healy has demonstrated great organizational and leadership skills as founder of the Lucky Striker Social Media Club, an industry trade group that meets regularly to discuss, develop, and promote marketing strategies with a focus on leveraging social media techniques and technologies." – Joe Sheehan of Weichert Realtors

"Patrick Healy's knowledge of online marketing dates back before Facebook, when Google was emerging as the disruptive technology marketers needed to leverage. With the rise of Facebook, he kept his skills sharp, honing his understanding of blogging, community, and social capital. He is a complete digital marketing guru." – Matt Browne of 

Choose a Topic

  • Business
  • Marketing
  • Technology
  • Operations
  • Social Media
  • Real Estate

Press this red button

  • Privacy Policy
  • Comment Policy and Rules
  • Copyright ©2010 – 2020 Phacient
  • Contact Us

Phacient
10030 Green Level Church Road, Suite 802-158,   Cary, NC 27519  •  Phone: 646-580-4070




654321
  Writing,images and video by Phacient Consulting is copyrighted and licensed under a Creative Commons License. Based on awork at www.phacient.com .Creative Commons License